Chemung County Death Raises OSI’s Scrutiny

New York – The New York Attorney General’s Office of Special Investigation (OSI) has thrown its weight behind a probe into the tragic death of Nathan Novakowski, who met his end on September 28, 2025, in Chemung County. The incident involved members of both the New York State Police (NYSP) and the Chemung County Sheriff’s Office (CCSO).

According to reports, the fateful encounter unfolded at around 2:58 p.m., following a domestic dispute call. Responding officers encountered Novakowski, who was purportedly menacing a woman with scissors. The trooper instructed Novakowski to surrender the scissors, but the civilian reportedly ignored the order. In response, the trooper discharged his service weapon, resulting in Novakowski’s death at the scene. The woman involved sustained minor injuries, and officers recovered the scissors from the scene.

Pursuant to New York State Executive Law Section 70-b, OSI is tasked with reviewing incidents where police or peace officers may have caused a fatality by act or omission, regardless of whether on-duty or off-duty, and irrespective of the decedent’s status. The OSI will proceed with a full investigation if their assessment indicates potential officer liability.

These are preliminary facts, and the situation remains fluid as the OSI delves into its inquiry.

The Chemung County tragedy has once again underscored the critical role played by the OSI in ensuring transparency and accountability within law enforcement. The public’s trust in police departments hinges on the thorough investigation of such incidents, and OSI’s intervention sends a clear message that every life lost at the hands of law enforcement is of utmost importance.

New York’s Attorney General James’ Office stands firm in its commitment to justice, as it initiates this vital investigation into Chemung County’s civilian death. The OSI will leave no stone unturned to get to the bottom of this tragedy and uphold the rule of law.