Middleboro Financial Adviser Sentenced to Over Four Years in Prison for Investment Adviser Fraud and Money Laundering

Learn about the sentencing of a Middleboro financial adviser for investment fraud and money laundering. Find out the details of the case and the impact on victims.

In a recent case out of Massachusetts, a financial adviser from Middleboro has been sentenced to over four years in prison for investment adviser fraud and money laundering. Paul R. McGonigle, 67, was convicted of defrauding his elderly and vulnerable clients, stealing their retirement assets, and causing unauthorized withdrawals from their annuities. The victims ranged from the elderly to individuals with dementia and cognitive impairments. McGonigle used the stolen money for personal and business expenses, while falsely assuring clients that their investments were growing. With an increasing number of investment scams costing consumers billions of dollars, this case highlights the commitment of law enforcement to hold fraudsters accountable and protect vulnerable victims from financial exploitation.


Paul R. McGonigle, a financial adviser from Middleboro, has been sentenced to 54 months in prison for investment adviser fraud and money laundering. In addition to his prison sentence, McGonigle has been ordered to pay restitution of $652,987 to his victims. This article will provide an overview of the case, McGonigle’s role as a financial adviser, the victims of the fraud, and the duration of the fraudulent activities.


In this section, we will provide an overview of the case, outlining the key events and developments.

Paul R. McGonigle worked as a financial adviser, providing investment advice and managing retirement assets for his clients. However, it was discovered that McGonigle had been defrauding his clients, particularly targeting elderly and vulnerable individuals. The fraud involved unauthorized withdrawals from victims’ annuities and the misappropriation of funds for personal and business expenses. McGonigle also impersonated clients on phone calls and provided false assurances about the growth of their investments.

The fraud carried out by McGonigle lasted for several years, causing significant financial harm to his victims. This section will provide more details about the victims and the duration of the fraudulent activities.

Charges and Plea

In February 2023, Paul R. McGonigle entered a guilty plea for his involvement in the fraudulent activities. This section will outline the specific charges against him and provide an explanation of his guilty plea.

McGonigle faced several charges, including investment adviser fraud, money laundering, wire fraud, mail fraud, and aggravated identity theft. These charges reflect the various fraudulent activities he engaged in, such as unauthorized withdrawals, misappropriation of funds, and impersonation of clients. McGonigle pled guilty to these charges, acknowledging his actions and accepting responsibility for his crimes.


This section will cover the details of McGonigle’s sentencing, including the length of his prison term, the terms of his supervised release, and the amount of restitution he is obligated to pay.

U.S. District Court Judge Nathaniel M. Gorton sentenced McGonigle to 54 months in prison, reflecting the severity of his crimes and the impact they had on his victims. Additionally, McGonigle will serve two months of supervised release following the completion of his prison term, during which he will be closely monitored.

As part of his sentencing, McGonigle has been ordered to pay restitution of $652,987 to his victims. This amount represents the funds he fraudulently obtained from his clients and is intended to compensate them for their financial losses.

Statements from Authorities

This section will include statements from relevant authorities involved in the case, such as Joshua S. Levy (Acting United States Attorney) and Christopher DiMenna (Acting Special Agent in Charge of the FBI Boston Division). These statements will provide insight into the impact of McGonigle’s crimes and demonstrate the commitment of law enforcement agencies to hold fraudsters accountable.

Description of the Fraud Scheme

In this section, we will provide a detailed description of the fraud scheme carried out by McGonigle. This description will include the various tactics he used to defraud his victims and the methods he employed to cover up his actions.

McGonigle’s fraud scheme involved unauthorized withdrawals from victims’ annuities, which he used for personal and business expenses. He also induced victims to give him money to invest on their behalf, which he subsequently misappropriated. To conceal his actions, McGonigle impersonated clients on calls with their annuity companies and forged their signatures on withdrawal forms. In addition, he provided false assurances to his clients, leading them to believe that their investments were growing.

Assistance and Support

This section will highlight the role of the Massachusetts Insurance Fraud Bureau in assisting with the investigation of McGonigle’s fraudulent activities. The information provided will emphasize the importance of collaboration between law enforcement agencies and regulatory bodies in combating financial fraud.

The Massachusetts Insurance Fraud Bureau played a crucial role in the investigation of McGonigle’s fraud scheme. Their expertise and resources were instrumental in uncovering the extent of his crimes, aiding in the prosecution of the case, and providing support to the victims.

Prosecution and Legal Team

This section will acknowledge the individuals involved in the prosecution of Paul R. McGonigle and highlight their contributions to the successful outcome of the case.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Kristen A. Kearney, from the Securities, Financial & Cyber Fraud Unit, prosecuted the case against McGonigle. Her expertise in financial fraud and dedication to seeking justice for victims were vital in securing McGonigle’s guilty plea and subsequent sentencing.

Other Related Cases

This section will briefly mention other cases related to financial fraud and money laundering to emphasize the broader efforts to combat these crimes. It will provide a summary of these cases without going into extensive detail.

The article will mention specific cases, such as an Acton man being sentenced for COVID relief funds fraud, a Rhode Island business owner pleading guilty to money laundering conspiracy and obstruction of justice, and a Rhode Island man being sentenced for the misuse of COVID-19 pandemic assistance. These cases demonstrate the ongoing efforts to identify and prosecute individuals involved in financial fraud and money laundering schemes.

Contact Information

This section will provide contact information for the USAO-MA (United States Attorney’s Office for the District of Massachusetts) offices in Boston, Springfield, and Worcester. The contact information will include the office addresses and phone numbers, allowing readers to seek further assistance or information if needed.