Carlisle Arsonist Faces 40 Years for Setting Fire to Local Businesses

A Carlisle man is facing a lengthy prison sentence after being indicted on federal charges of arson and malicious damage to property. John Petonyak, 46, of Carlisle, was charged on June 18, 2025, by a federal grand jury with two counts of arson.

According to Acting United States Attorney John C. Gurganus, the indictment alleges that on August 11, 2021, Petonyak maliciously set fire to materials associated with two buildings in Carlisle: The Gingerbread Man, located on S. Court House Avenue; and Faye’s Kitchen, located on S. Hanover Street.

The case was investigated by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives; the Carlisle Police Department; and the Pennsylvania State Police. Assistant U.S. Attorney Scott Ford is prosecuting the case.

Petonyak faces a maximum penalty of 40 years imprisonment, a term of supervised release following imprisonment, and a fine. A sentence following a finding of guilt is imposed by the Judge after consideration of the applicable federal sentencing statutes and the Federal Sentencing Guidelines.

The indictment and subsequent charges are a stark reminder of the devastating consequences of arson and malicious damage to property. The destruction of local businesses can have a ripple effect on the community, impacting not only the owners but also employees and customers.

The investigation and prosecution of this case are a testament to the dedication and hard work of law enforcement agencies and prosecutors who work tirelessly to bring justice to those affected by crime.

The case is a prime example of the importance of holding individuals accountable for their actions and ensuring that justice is served. As the investigation continues, we will keep a close eye on the developments and provide updates as necessary.

Indictments and Criminal Informations are only allegations. All persons charged are presumed to be innocent unless and until found guilty in court.