Chemung Cop Fatality Under AG James’ Scrutiny

New York – The New York Attorney General’s Office of Special Investigation (OSI) has embarked on an investigation following the tragic shooting death of Nathan Novakowski in Chemung County. The incident, which occurred on September 28, 2025, involved New York State Police (NYSP) and Chemung County Sheriff’s Office (CCSO) officers responding to a domestic dispute.

The encounter took a dire turn when Mr. Novakowski, reportedly armed with scissors, failed to comply with an officer’s order to drop the weapon. The trooper then discharged his service weapon, resulting in Mr. Novakowski’s death at the scene. A woman involved in the dispute sustained minor injuries.

The OSI is mandated by New York State Executive Law Section 70-b to assess such incidents where police or peace officers may have caused a civilian’s death through action or inaction. The law applies regardless of an officer’s duty status, the decedent’s armed status, or whether they were in custody.

OSI will proceed with a thorough investigation if their assessment indicates any officer might be responsible for the death of Mr. Novakowski. This preliminary information is subject to change as the investigation unfolds.

This incident serves as another stark reminder of the ongoing need for scrutiny and accountability within law enforcement agencies across New York State.