The streets of Augusta were abuzz with the gruesome discovery of a lifeless body found in the city. The man, later identified as Nalbandian, a 32-year-old Armenian, had been missing from his boarding house at 72 Church Street since Saturday. His identity was confirmed through the testimony of Milton Tooten, a shoe worker, and a notebook found on his person.
A somber atmosphere settled over the city as the news of Nalbandian’s demise spread. The police, determined to unravel the mystery, scoured the local Armenian resorts in search of any leads on his whereabouts. The investigation was further complicated by the use of an alias, ‘Frank Jones,’ which added to the enigma.
Former associates of Nalbandian revealed that they hadn’t seen him in Lynn for many days, fueling speculation about his disappearance. The police, however, remained tight-lipped about the case, leaving many questions unanswered. The identity of the victim, though confirmed, only added to the mystery surrounding his death.
As the police continued their investigation, arrangements were made for Nalbandian’s burial in Mt. Hope Cemetery, in the Monjian family lot, where his sister, accompanied by an interpreter, had come to identify the body. The silence surrounding the case only added to the intrigue, leaving the citizens of Augusta to ponder the circumstances surrounding Nalbandian’s tragic end.
The search for answers continued, but the truth behind Nalbandian’s identity and demise remained elusive. As the city struggled to come to terms with the brutal discovery, the police remained committed to uncovering the truth behind the Armenian man’s mysterious death.
The case of Nalbandian’s identity theft and subsequent death remained one of the most baffling mysteries to plague the city of Augusta in 1909. The investigation, though ongoing, seemed to be at a standstill, leaving the public to wonder if the truth would ever be revealed.
Related Federal Cases
Key Facts
- State: ME
- Category: Violent Crime
- Era: Historical
- Source: Library of Congress — Chronicling America ↗
📬 Get the grimiest stories delivered weekly. Subscribe free →
Browse More

