Bob J. Lerum, Asbestos Violations, MT 2003

Billings, MT – A dangerous disregard for public health and safety led to criminal charges and financial penalties for Bob J. Lerum and two associates in 2003, following an improperly conducted asbestos abatement project at a Montana child care facility. The case, investigated by state environmental authorities, revealed a systemic failure to adhere to regulations designed to protect workers and the public from the harmful effects of asbestos exposure.

According to court documents, Lerum, along with co-defendants Crist and Dummett, initiated renovations at the facility without first conducting a mandatory inspection for asbestos-containing materials. This initial oversight set the stage for a series of further violations, ultimately creating a hazardous environment for those present at the facility, particularly vulnerable children.

The investigation uncovered that the defendants not only skipped the crucial pre-renovation inspection but also contracted individuals who lacked the necessary asbestos abatement certification to perform the work. This constituted a direct breach of state regulations and exposed unqualified workers to potentially lethal asbestos fibers. Further compounding the issue, the abatement project proceeded without obtaining the required permits from the Montana Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ).

On August 29, 2002, charges were formally filed against Lerum, Crist, and Dummett. Each defendant faced six counts: one count of contracting with an unaccredited person, two counts of failing to inspect for asbestos before renovation, and two counts of performing an asbestos project without a permit, as well as one count of conducting an asbestos project without a permit. The charges stemmed from violations of Montana Code Annotated (MCA) sections 75-2-516, 75-2-503(1), and 75-2-511(2)(b) & (c). These statutes specifically govern asbestos management and abatement procedures within the state.

In January and February of 2003, all three defendants entered guilty pleas. Lerum and Crist each received sentences requiring a $120 special assessment fee and $3,000 in fines, with $750 of the fines suspended. Dummett faced a slightly reduced penalty of a $100 special assessment fee and $2,500 in fines, with $400 suspended. While the financial penalties represent a degree of accountability, critics argue that they are insufficient given the potential long-term health consequences associated with asbestos exposure and the vulnerability of the affected population – young children.

This case serves as a stark reminder of the critical importance of strict adherence to environmental regulations, particularly when dealing with hazardous materials like asbestos. The failure to comply with these regulations not only endangers lives but also undermines public trust in those responsible for ensuring a safe environment. The GrimyTimes will continue to follow environmental crime cases and report on the consequences of negligent and illegal practices.

Key Facts

Defendant: Bob J. Lerum, Crist, and Dummett
Location: Montana
Year: 2003
Crime: Improper asbestos abatement at a child care facility
Statutes Violated: MCA 75-2-516, MCA 75-2-503(1), MCA 75-2-511(2)(b) & (c)
Penalties: Lerum & Crist – $120 assessment + $3,000 fine ($750 suspended); Dummett – $100 assessment + $2,500 fine ($400 suspended)
Key Violations: Failure to inspect for asbestos, contracting uncertified personnel, performing work without a permit.

Source: EPA ECHO Enforcement Case Database

Related Federal Cases