Charles A. Donahoo, Jr., Environmental Crime, KY 1990

Louisville, KY – Charles A. Donahoo, Jr., operating as Charlie Wrecking, received a suspended sentence and probation following a jury conviction in 1989 for violations of federal environmental law. The case, stemming from a demolition project in Jefferson County, Kentucky, highlights the increasing scrutiny of asbestos handling and hazardous substance reporting within the demolition industry.

According to court documents, Donahoo’s company contracted with Tuscarora Plastics to demolish a building in Louisville. The subsequent investigation by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) revealed significant breaches in established safety protocols regarding asbestos removal and hazardous waste management. The indictment, filed in June of 1989, alleged Donahoo knowingly removed and emitted friable asbestos without adhering to mandated standards, potentially exposing workers and the public to the dangerous substance.

The charges weren’t limited to improper asbestos handling. Donahoo was also accused of failing to report the release of hazardous substances, a direct violation of federal regulations designed to ensure swift containment and mitigation of environmental risks. Furthermore, the indictment included a count of making false statements to authorities, hindering the investigation into the alleged environmental violations. Investigators believe Donahoo attempted to mislead officials regarding the scope and nature of the asbestos abatement work.

After a contentious jury trial, Donahoo was found guilty on one count each of violating the Clean Air Act and the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA), also known as Superfund. While facing multiple charges, the jury evidently found sufficient evidence to convict on these two key offenses. The verdict sent a clear message that deliberate disregard for environmental regulations will not be tolerated.

Table of Contents

Key Facts

Defendant: Charles A. Donahoo, Jr. d/b/a Charlie Wrecking
Location: Jefferson County, Kentucky
Laws Violated: 18 U.S.C. 1001 (False Statements), 42 U.S.C. 7412(c) & (e) [Clean Air Act – Asbestos Removal], 42 U.S.C. 9603(b) [CERCLA – Failure to Report Hazardous Substance Release]
Sentence: 12 months and 36 months incarceration (concurrent, with all but six months suspended), 36 months probation, $75 to Crime Victim’s Fund.
Incident Date: 1989
Industry: Demolition/Wrecking

On December 19, 1989, the court sentenced Donahoo to concurrent terms of 12 and 36 months imprisonment, with all but six months of the sentence suspended. He was also placed on 36 months of probation and ordered to pay a $75 assessment to the Crime Victim’s Fund. While the sentence included incarceration, the significant suspension suggests the court acknowledged mitigating factors or a degree of cooperation. However, the conviction and probationary period remain a matter of public record, serving as a cautionary tale for others in the demolition industry. The EPA continues to aggressively pursue enforcement actions against those who flout environmental regulations, prioritizing public health and environmental protection.

GrimyTimes will continue to follow developments in environmental crime cases and provide in-depth reporting on the individuals and companies held accountable for endangering our communities.

Source: EPA ECHO Enforcement Case Database

Related Federal Cases