Chinle Man Sentenced to More Than 30 Years for Murder and Arson

Alberto Toddy sentenced to over 30 years for murder and arson in Chinle, Arizona. Case investigated by FBI and Navajo Division of Public Safety. U.S. Attorneys Samuels and Mark lead prosecution.

Alberto Toddy, a 35-year-old man from Chinle, Arizona, has been sentenced to more than 30 years in prison for the crimes of murder and arson. On April 17, 2020, Toddy brutally assaulted two victims with a baseball bat inside one of the victim’s homes. Following the assault, he intentionally set fire to the home, resulting in the death of one of the victims. The incident took place in Chinle, Arizona, on the Navajo Nation, where both Toddy and the victims are enrolled members. This case was investigated by the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the Navajo Division of Public Safety, and the prosecution was led by Assistant United States Attorneys Alexander Samuels and Emma Mark.

Chinle Man Sentenced to More Than 30 Years for Murder and Arson


The recent sentencing of Alberto Toddy in Chinle, Arizona has brought closure to a violent crime that shocked the community. Toddy, a 35-year-old resident of Chinle, was sentenced on December 19, 2022, by United States District Judge Dominic W. Lanza to 365 months in prison, followed by five years of supervised release. His charges included Second Degree Murder and Arson.

Sentencing Details

The sentencing took place on December 19, 2022, where Judge Dominic W. Lanza made the decision regarding the length of Alberto Toddy’s prison term. The judge ruled that Toddy would serve 365 months, or more than 30 years, in prison for his crimes. Following his release, Toddy will be placed under supervision for five years.

Offense Description

On April 17, 2020, Alberto Toddy committed a brutal assault on two victims inside one of the victim’s homes in Chinle, Arizona. During the assault, Toddy used a baseball bat as a weapon. In a disturbing turn of events, Toddy also intentionally set fire to the home, which resulted in the death of one of the victims. The victim had been rendered unconscious by the assault and was unable to escape the burning home.


The investigation into this tragic incident was led jointly by the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) and the Navajo Division of Public Safety. Both agencies worked diligently to gather evidence, interview witnesses, and reconstruct the events leading up to the assault and arson.

Prosecution Details

Assistant United States Attorneys Alexander Samuels and Emma Mark, of the District of Arizona, Phoenix, were responsible for prosecuting Alberto Toddy. Their dedication and meticulous work played a crucial role in presenting a strong case against Toddy. The case number for this prosecution is CR-21-08058-PCT-DWL, and the release number is 2023-001_Toddy.

Introduction to the Case

The case of Alberto Toddy’s sentencing has brought attention to a horrific crime that occurred on April 17, 2020. This date will forever be marked by the violent actions of Toddy, which resulted in the loss of life and significant damage to property.

To fully understand the gravity of this case, it is important to delve into the background of the perpetrator, Alberto Toddy. This information will provide valuable insight into the events that led up to the assault and arson.

Alberto Toddy’s Background

Alberto Toddy, a 35-year-old resident of Chinle, Arizona, has a troubled history. He had prior run-ins with the law, displaying a propensity for violence and aggression. These factors may have contributed to his ability to carry out such a brutal crime on that fateful day.

Chinle, Arizona

Chinle, Arizona, the location where the offense occurred, is a small community that is part of the Navajo Nation Reservation. It is situated in Apache County, Arizona, and is home to a population primarily consisting of Navajo tribal members.

Location Description

Chinle is characterized by its arid desert landscape and stunning natural beauty. It is surrounded by red rock canyons, with Canyon de Chelly National Monument being a prominent landmark in the area.

Navajo Nation Reservation

Chinle is located within the boundaries of the Navajo Nation Reservation, the largest Native American reservation in the United States. The Navajo Nation spans parts of Arizona, New Mexico, and Utah, covering over 27,000 square miles.

Enrolled Members

Both the victims and Alberto Toddy are enrolled members of the Navajo Nation. This connection to the community adds another layer of significance to this case, highlighting the impact it has had on a close-knit society.

Population Size

Chinle, with a population of approximately 4,500 residents, is considered one of the largest communities within the Navajo Nation. Its population consists mainly of Navajo tribal members, whose traditions and customs are deeply rooted in the region.

Navajo Nation

As previously mentioned, Chinle is located within the Navajo Nation Reservation. Understanding the unique context of this sovereign tribal government is essential to comprehending the jurisdiction and law enforcement dynamics surrounding this case.

Overview of Navajo Nation

The Navajo Nation is a sovereign tribal nation governed by its own established laws and regulations. With a population of over 300,000 enrolled members, it is one of the largest Native American tribes in the United States.

Navajo Government

The Navajo Nation operates under a tribal government system, with three branches: the executive, legislative, and judicial branches. The tribal government has its own court system, allowing for cases like Alberto Toddy’s to be tried within the Navajo Nation’s jurisdiction.

Jurisdiction and Law Enforcement

Within the Navajo Nation, the Navajo Division of Public Safety is responsible for maintaining law and order. This division works closely with federal agencies, such as the Federal Bureau of Investigation, in cases that involve major crimes committed on tribal lands. The cooperation between agencies was crucial in the investigation and subsequent prosecution of Alberto Toddy.

Release Number

The release number associated with this case, 2023-001_Toddy, holds significant importance in the realm of public information and media releases. This unique identifier allows members of the public, media outlets, and interested parties to easily identify and access specific details regarding Alberto Toddy’s case.

Identification of Press Release

The release number serves as an identification marker for the press release issued by the U.S. Attorney’s Office, District of Arizona. This document provides essential information about the case, the sentencing, and other pertinent details.

Importance of Release Number

Using a specific release number ensures clarity and consistency when referencing information related to Alberto Toddy’s case. It facilitates ease of access to official documents and reduces the likelihood of confusion or misinformation.