Frank O’Toole, Stolen Firearms Sale, Massachusetts 2024

BOSTON – A Middleborough, Massachusetts man got a slap on the wrist this week after admitting to pilfering guns from the very packages he was paid to deliver. Frank P. O’Toole, 40, was sentenced to a mere six days in prison – time he’d already served – after pleading guilty to two counts of possession or sale of a stolen firearm. Federal prosecutors had recommended a ten-month stretch, a suggestion Judge Angel Kelley apparently ignored.

According to court documents, O’Toole, a former FedEx delivery truck driver, systematically stole three packages between October 2021 and June 2022. Each contained a firearm – two rifles and a shotgun – all destined for a licensed Federal Firearms Licensee. Instead of delivering them to their lawful owners, O’Toole flipped the stolen goods, selling them to an undercover agent during two separate meetings in August 2022.

The ATF, leading the investigation, built a case showing O’Toole wasn’t just negligent; he actively sought out packages containing firearms. The brazen theft speaks to a clear disregard for the law and the potential danger of putting weapons into the hands of criminals. The fact that he was able to complete the sales to an undercover agent demonstrates a calculated effort to profit from his crimes.

While O’Toole avoided significant jail time, he will spend the next three years under supervised release. As part of the sentence, he’s also been ordered to complete 250 hours of community service – a paltry requirement considering the gravity of his offense. The light sentence is sure to raise eyebrows among those who believe in stricter penalties for gun crimes, especially those involving the intentional theft and resale of weapons.

Acting United States Attorney Joshua S. Levy, along with James M. Ferguson, Special Agent in Charge of the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms & Explosives, and Middleborough Police Chief Joseph Perkins, announced the sentencing on Tuesday. Assistant U.S. Attorney Elianna J. Nuzum of the Major Crimes Unit handled the prosecution. The case highlights the ongoing efforts of federal and local agencies to combat illegal firearms trafficking.

Grimy Times will continue to follow this case and investigate the factors that led to such a lenient sentence. The public deserves to know why a man who stole and sold guns received only six days in prison, while others face far harsher penalties for similar offenses. The question remains: was justice served in this case, or did O’Toole simply get lucky?

MORE FEDERAL CRIME NEWS

Weapons

Erika LaRae Williams, False Statement, Arizona 2020

Apr 9, 2026

Weapons

Ellourth Eladio Simon, Unlicensed Firearms Dealing, California 2024

Apr 8, 2026

Weapons

Virgil Running Bear, Jr., Possession of a Firearm by a Prohibited Person, South Dakota 2013

Jun 22, 2015

Weapons

Rontavis Davis, Possession of a Firearm by a Convicted Felon, Georgia 2018

Feb 4, 2019