Caitlin Kenney, Bank Embezzlement, New York 2017

ALBANY, NY – Caitlin Kenney, 33, of Clifton Park, New York, is headed to federal prison after being sentenced today to 21 months for systematically pilfering nearly half a million dollars from KeyBank, N.A. The former head teller used her position to bleed the bank dry over a four-year period, funding a lifestyle fueled by both retail therapy and hard drugs.

The sentencing, handed down by Senior United States District Judge Thomas J. McAvoy, concludes a case brought by the U.S. Attorney’s Office and investigated by the Albany Field Office of the Federal Bureau of Investigation. U.S. Attorney Grant C. Jaquith and FBI Special Agent in Charge James N. Hendricks announced the outcome, a small victory in a landscape riddled with financial predation.

According to court documents, Kenney’s scheme unfolded between September 2013 and February 2017 at KeyBank branches in Queensbury and Malta, New York. As a head teller, Kenney had access to substantial cash reserves. She exploited this access, transferring funds from the bank’s vaults into unused cashboxes – a classic move for a desperate thief – and then simply pocketing the money.

But Kenney didn’t just grab cash; she attempted to cover her tracks. She manipulated KeyBank’s electronic accounting system, falsifying records in a transparent attempt to mask the missing funds. The scheme ultimately unraveled, revealing a total loss of $483,784.83. The money, prosecutors revealed, was spent on frivolous purchases – clothes, vacations – and a significant amount on cocaine, illustrating a pattern of reckless self-indulgence.

The 21-month prison sentence isn’t the end of Kenney’s legal troubles. Judge McAvoy also imposed a two-year term of supervised release, to begin after her incarceration. Crucially, Kenney is now legally obligated to repay the full $483,784.83 she stole from KeyBank, a restitution order that will likely haunt her long after she’s released.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Cyrus P.W. Rieck prosecuted the case, building a solid case based on FBI investigative work. While Kenney’s sentence sends a message that such crimes will be punished, it remains to be seen whether it will deter others from similar acts of betrayal and greed. The Grimy Times will continue to follow this case and other instances of financial crime within the federal system.

Related Federal Cases