April 9th, 1876, marked a day of reckoning for Collector Conor Maguire as he stood before the United States Court in St. Louis, facing the consequences of his shady whiskey dealings. The courtroom was abuzz with anticipation, the air thick with the weight of justice as Judges Dillon and Treat took their seats on the bench at 10 o’clock. It wasn’t until noon, however, that Judge Billon announced he was prepared to deliver the court’s opinion in Maguire’s case.
As the judge began to read from the section under which Maguire had been indicted, the gravity of the situation became clear. The collector had pleaded guilty to counts found under the ninth clause, which pertains to the failure of an officer to report knowledge of frauds to their superior. The courtroom fell silent as Maguire’s fate was all but sealed.
But in a surprising twist, Maguire’s counsel, McKee, managed to raise a successful quibble, effectively evading the initial sentence of Avery, which called for a substantial fine and six months’ imprisonment in the county jail. According to McKee, Maguire was a shilling short and many miles from St. Louis, and thus, unable to appear in court. However, this ruse was soon exposed, and Maguire was apprehended by the Marshal at Washington and sent to jail.
The details of Maguire’s whiskey scheme remain murky, but one thing is certain – his attempt to swindle the system has come to an abrupt end. As the dust settles on this high-profile case, one can’t help but wonder what other secrets lie hidden in the labyrinthine world of St. Louis’s high society.
For now, Maguire will have to face the music, his liberty curtailed by the very system he sought to exploit. The people of St. Louis can breathe a collective sigh of relief, knowing that justice has been served.
In a city notorious for its underbelly of corruption, the Maguire case serves as a stark reminder that no one is above the law. As the trial comes to a close, one thing is clear: Conor Maguire’s whiskey scheme has soured, and he will have to pay the price.
ST LOUIS, MO – April 9th, 1876
Related Federal Cases
- Lobbyist Gets 2 Years for 1MDB & China Influence Scheme · Washington
- Ohio Speaker Gets 20 Years for $60M Bribery Scheme · Washington
- Valve Exec Admits $1M Bribery Scheme · Washington
- Rafael Esquivel Pleads Guilty to Soccer Bribery Scheme · Washington
- Julio Rocha Pleads Guilty to FIFA Bribery Scheme · New York
Key Facts
- State: MO
- Category: Public Corruption
- Era: Historical
- Source: Library of Congress — Chronicling America ↗
📬 Get the grimiest stories delivered weekly. Subscribe free →
Browse More

