In 1858, New York City’s Society Hall was abuzz with debate over the efficacy of capital punishment in deterring murder. The question loomed large: could the taking of a life to avenge another’s truly be a just measure? One writer, perhaps a philosopher or a lawyer, weighed in with a provocative argument. He posited that human nature is elevated when a life is sacrificed for the greater good, and that the condemned man’s fate serves as a deterrent to others.
RELATED: Blazing Infernos Strike Manhattan: A Weekend of Destruction
RELATED: Murder in Manhattan: A Despicable Deed Unfolds on the Streets of New York
Related Federal Cases
- Ghoul Admits to Celebrating CEO’s Murder, Tormenting Family · New York
- Ukraine Fugitive Nabbed in Syracuse: Cops Allege Attempted Murder · New York
- Lower East Side Shootout: NYPD Cleared in Kent Edwards’ Death · New York
- Watson Morgan Triple Murder · New York
- Debra Arno Pleads Guilty in $20K Murder-for-Hire Plot · New York
Key Facts
- State: National
- Category: Violent Crime
- Era: Historical
- Source: Library of Congress — Chronicling America ↗
📬 Get the grimiest stories delivered weekly. Subscribe free →
Browse More