BRANCHVILLE, SC – Caleb Elias Hartzog, Jr. was sentenced to two years of probation and a $500 fine in September 2018 after pleading guilty to making false statements to a government agency, a federal crime. The case, investigated by the Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) Criminal Investigation Division, revealed a deliberate scheme to falsify water sampling reports for the town of Branchville, potentially jeopardizing public health.
Hartzog, who previously served as a drinking water operator for the small South Carolina town, admitted to forging certifications indicating that residents had provided samples for lead and copper contamination testing. Evidence presented in court detailed at least ten instances where Hartzog falsified documents, claiming samples were collected from homes when, in reality, no such collection had occurred – or had not occurred for a considerable period. Several residents testified that they had never provided samples during the relevant period in 2014.
The Falsified Forms
The crux of the case rested on the falsified forms required by the EPA to ensure the safety of the town’s drinking water. These forms require a resident’s signature, verifying they personally collected the water sample according to specific guidelines. Hartzog’s actions bypassed this critical safety measure, raising concerns about the accuracy of the town’s water quality reports submitted to state and federal regulators. Investigators discovered that none of the ten residents whose forms were scrutinized had actually signed the documents, indicating a clear intent to deceive.
No Contamination Found, But Concerns Remain
While subsequent testing, conducted after Hartzog’s departure, ultimately revealed no evidence of lead or copper contamination in Branchville’s water supply, the EPA emphasized the seriousness of the offense. The agency argued that the falsification of data undermines the entire water testing process, potentially leaving residents vulnerable to undetected hazards. The EPA’s criminal enforcement program aims to deter such actions and maintain the integrity of environmental regulations.
Legal Ramifications
Hartzog’s actions violated Title 18 U.S. Criminal Code § 1001(a)(3), which specifically addresses making false statements to a government agency. This federal statute carries a maximum penalty of five years in prison and a fine of up to $250,000. In Hartzog’s case, the court opted for a lighter sentence of two years’ probation and a $500 fine, likely considering the absence of actual contamination and a plea agreement. However, the case serves as a warning to others in positions of public trust.
Key Facts
- Defendant: Caleb Elias Hartzog, Jr.
- Location: Branchville, South Carolina
- Year of Offense: 2014 (charges filed 2018)
- Crime: Making a False Statement to a Government Agency
- Statute Violated: 18 U.S.C. § 1001(a)(3)
- Penalty: 2 years probation, $500 fine
- Impact: Falsified water sampling reports for lead and copper testing.
The case highlights the importance of diligent oversight and accountability within public water systems. The EPA continues to investigate potential violations of environmental regulations, aiming to protect communities from the risks associated with contaminated water supplies.
Source: EPA ECHO Enforcement Case Database
Related Federal Cases
- Albert Dickson, Making a False Statement Under the Clean Water Act,… · New Jersey
- Peter Zavell, Filed False Tax Return, Florence FL, 2000 · Mississippi
- Kenneth Knockum, Filing False Claims, California 2023 · South Carolina
- Peter Mwedziwendira, Filing False Personal Tax Returns, TX 2017 · South Carolina
- Benell English, Tax Return Preparer False Filings, Florida 2024 · Florida
MORE FEDERAL CRIME NEWS
White Collar CrimeWhite Collar CrimeWhite Collar CrimeWhite Collar Crime