POWHATAN, OH – A massive pollution incident impacting a pristine Ohio waterway has resulted in criminal convictions and hefty penalties for Ohio Valley Coal Company (OVCC) and two of its managers, according to court documents and a Department of Justice press release. In February 2008, approximately 22 miles of Captina Creek turned black following a slurry discharge from OVCC’s Number 2 Slurry Impoundment, jeopardizing a unique and sensitive ecosystem.
The incident stemmed from a deliberate circumvention of environmental regulations. OVCC had received permission to relocate a decant structure for its slurry impoundment, but instead of adhering to the stipulations of its National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permit—which required sampling and monitoring of effluent—the company began pumping water to the new location *without* any oversight. Plant Manager Don Meadows directed the operation, with the knowledge of Environmental Coordinator David Bartsch, and evidence suggests both men attempted to conceal their actions after the spill occurred.
The initial discharge on February 28, 2008, wasn’t an isolated incident. Unmonitored discharges continued throughout January and February, escalating into the catastrophic slurry release. Captina Creek, designated an Outstanding State Water by the Ohio EPA and an Aquatic Resource of National Interest by the U.S. EPA, is a critical habitat for numerous species, including the federally threatened and state endangered Eastern Hellbender salamander – the only known breeding location for the species within Ohio. The pollution posed a significant threat to this vulnerable population and the creek’s overall ecological health.
Criminal Charges and Sentences
David Bartsch was charged on January 27, 2011, with violating the Clean Water Act (33 U.S.C. 1319(c)(1)) for knowingly failing to report the discharges. He subsequently pleaded guilty on February 16, 2011, and was sentenced on May 26, 2011, to 12 months of probation, a $2,500 federal fine, and 104 hours of community service – to be served during company time. Donald Meadows faced similar charges on March 8, 2011, pleading guilty on March 28, 2011. His sentence, handed down on June 22, 2011, included 12 months of probation, a $2,500 fine, and 156 hours of community service.
OVCC itself faced two counts of violating the Clean Water Act and pleaded guilty on July 13, 2012. The company was sentenced on August 1, 2012, to pay a $500,000 criminal fine to the United States and $87,000 in restitution to the Ohio EPA for analysis and creek protection. Additionally, OVCC was placed on a one-year probation period, during which it is required to develop and submit a slurry release prevention and emergency response plan to the Ohio EPA for approval. A second incident in October 2010, involving a pipeline rupture, further contributed to the penalties levied against the company.
Long-Term Remediation and Prevention
Beyond the fines and probation, OVCC has committed to a substantial investment in infrastructure improvements. The company has reportedly spent over $6 million to install a double-walled pipeline system designed to enhance pipeline integrity and prevent future spills. This commitment, coupled with the mandated slurry release prevention plan, represents an attempt to mitigate the long-term environmental damage and prevent similar incidents from occurring. The case underscores the critical importance of adhering to environmental regulations and the potential consequences of prioritizing profit over environmental protection.
Key Facts
- Defendant: Ohio Valley Coal Company (OVCC), David Bartsch, Donald Meadows
- Crime: Violations of the Clean Water Act (33 U.S.C. 1319(c)(1))
- Location: Captina Creek, Powhatan, Ohio
- Date of Incident: February 28, 2008 (primary slurry release)
- Penalties: OVCC – $500,000 fine, $87,000 restitution, one-year probation, $6M pipeline upgrade. Bartsch & Meadows – $2,500 fine, 12 months probation, 104-156 hours community service.
- Environmental Impact: 22 miles of Captina Creek polluted, threat to endangered Hellbender salamander habitat.
- Additional Penalties: $91,000 penalty and $4,000 for natural resource damages to Ohio DNR, $368,000 in administrative penalties to Ohio EPA.
Source: EPA ECHO Enforcement Case Database
Related Federal Cases
- Ahmed A. Sh. Ahmed, Wire Fraud and False Statements, Ohio, 2023 · Ohio
- Russell W. Spitz, Bank and Wire Fraud, Ohio, 2023 · Ohio
- Divyesh “David” C. Patel, Medicaid and Medicare Fraud, OH, 2023 · Ohio
- Ohio Man Pleads Guilty to Dumping Toxic Drilling Waste, Youngstown … · Ohio
- David Donadeo, IT Scheme, Cuyahoga Heights OH, 2024 · Ohio
MORE FEDERAL CRIME NEWS
White Collar CrimeWhite Collar CrimeWhite Collar CrimeWhite Collar Crime