HENDERSONVILLE, TN – A Tennessee man has served time and paid restitution following a 2006 incident involving the illegal misapplication of pesticides that led to the deaths of multiple protected birds of prey. Dennis Gerald Plemons of Hendersonville was found guilty of violating state environmental regulations after a probe by state authorities revealed his actions directly contributed to the fatalities of at least four Red-Tailed Hawks.
According to court documents, Plemons was initially charged on June 1, 2006, with eleven counts relating to improper pesticide use. The specific pesticide involved, and the circumstances surrounding its misapplication, were not immediately disclosed by authorities at the time, but the investigation determined a clear link between Plemons’ actions and the subsequent avian deaths. The Red-Tailed Hawk is a protected species under both state and federal law, and any harm to these birds carries significant legal consequences.
The case underscored the potential dangers of improper pesticide application and the impact on local ecosystems. Environmental advocates have long warned about the risks posed to wildlife by careless handling of agricultural and pest control chemicals. While details of Plemons’ intent remain unclear, the outcome serves as a stark reminder of the responsibility landowners and applicators have to adhere to strict regulations designed to protect vulnerable species.
On September 27, 2006, Plemons entered a guilty plea to all eleven counts filed against him. The judge presiding over the case handed down a sentence of one and a half months incarceration, along with an order for restitution totaling $3,671. The restitution is believed to cover the cost of investigating the incident, as well as potential ecological damage assessments. Court records indicate the state successfully argued that Plemons’ negligence directly resulted in a quantifiable loss to the local environment.
Legal Ramifications
Plemons was convicted under Tennessee state environmental regulations concerning pesticide application and wildlife protection. The specific statutes violated were not publicly released, however, the charges indicate a breach of established protocols for safe pesticide handling, storage, and application. These regulations are designed to prevent contamination of the environment and protect non-target species, like the Red-Tailed Hawks in this case. The penalties for violating these statutes can range from fines and community service to jail time, depending on the severity of the offense and the extent of the damage caused.
Key Facts
- Defendant: Dennis Gerald Plemons
- State: Tennessee
- Year: 2006
- Crime: Illegal pesticide misapplication resulting in wildlife deaths
- Victims: At least four Red-Tailed Hawks
- Charges: 11 counts of violating state environmental regulations
- Sentence: 1.5 months incarceration and $3,671 restitution
The Plemons case remains a cautionary tale for pesticide applicators. Authorities continue to emphasize the importance of proper training, adherence to label instructions, and responsible environmental stewardship to prevent similar incidents from occurring in the future. GrimyTimes will continue to follow environmental crime cases across the nation, providing in-depth reporting on those who put profit over preservation.
Source: EPA ECHO Enforcement Case Database
Related Federal Cases

