August 6, 1870, marked a somber day in New York City as John Real met his maker on the gallows for the brutal murder of Police Officer John Smedick. Real had spent two long years awaiting his fate, a period marked by a desperate struggle to evade the hangman’s noose. But ultimately, the forces of justice prevailed, and beneath the bright summer sun, Real’s life was extinguished in a manner as swift as it was merciless.
The fateful encounter between Real and Smedick took place on the night of July 23, 1869, on First Avenue, near 32nd Street. It was a chance meeting that would prove to be Real’s undoing. The doomed man, with a mind turned turbulent by years of dissipation, had a naturally resolute character that had been warped by his path of self-destruction. His actions that night would seal his fate and leave a trail of sorrow in the wake of Officer Smedick’s untimely death.
Real’s trial was a contentious and bungling affair, marred by delays and appeals that only served to prolong the condemned man’s agony. But with the inevitable drawing near, Real’s hopes for a reprieve were finally extinguished. As the clock struck 10 o’clock yesterday morning, the black cap was slipped over Real’s face, and the condemned man took his final breath, a victim of his own crimes as well as the unforgiving hand of justice.
John Real’s execution serves as a grim reminder of the consequences of crime in a city that values order and stability above all else. It is a stark warning to those who would seek to follow in the footsteps of the doomed man, and a testament to the bravery and dedication of the men and women who serve and protect this great metropolis.
Related Federal Cases
- 1983 NY Federal Drug Smuggling Ring Unleashes Justice · New York
- 1983 NY Federal Crime: Sentence Served · New York
- Buffalo Snitch Jeffrey Mills Faces Life for Obstructing Justice · New York
- Hate-Fueled Threats: NYC Woman Targets Denver LGBTQ Spots · Colorado
- Bronx Man Nabbed in Dementia Patient Abduction · New York
Key Facts
- State: National
- Category: Violent Crime
- Era: Historical
- Source: Library of Congress — Chronicling America ↗
📬 Get the grimiest stories delivered weekly. Subscribe free →
Browse More

