Matthew Garrett Mink, Possessing an Illegal Machinegun, Florida 2022

NAPLES, FL – Matthew Garrett Mink, 38, of Naples, Florida, is headed to federal prison after being sentenced to four years and three months for a cache of illegal weaponry. U.S. District Judge Sheri Polster Chappell handed down the sentence Monday, along with a $20,000 fine and forfeiture of the firearms and silencers involved.

Mink, a former manager at a Naples-licensed gun dealer, initially came under scrutiny after being terminated from his position. A subsequent federal investigation, spearheaded by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF), quickly revealed a pattern of brazen disregard for the law. Mink wasn’t just skirting the rules; he was actively engaged in a criminal enterprise, both during and after his time at the gun shop.

Court records detail a litany of offenses. Mink pleaded guilty on May 2, 2022, to possessing an illegal machinegun, an unregistered firearm silencer, a stolen firearm silencer, and an un-serialized firearm silencer. The investigation showed Mink falsified paperwork related to the gun shop’s inventory, manipulating records to cover his illegal activities. Beyond the paperwork, he possessed modified machineguns, and a collection of silencers – some stolen, some built without serial numbers, all illegal.

The ATF’s investigation uncovered more than just possession. The specifics of how Mink acquired these weapons and his intent remain largely sealed within court documents, but the sheer volume of illegal items points to a calculated operation. The fact that he was a former manager of a licensed dealer raises serious questions about oversight and potential internal vulnerabilities within the firearms industry.

Assistant United States Attorney Simon R. Eth prosecuted the case, emphasizing the seriousness of the crimes. The sentencing is being touted as a win for Project Safe Neighborhoods (PSN), a Department of Justice program aimed at reducing violent crime and gun violence. However, critics argue PSN often focuses on punishment after the fact, rather than addressing the root causes of gun violence.

Mink’s case underscores the ongoing challenge of illegal firearms trafficking and the need for stricter enforcement of existing gun laws. While the ATF secured a conviction and a lengthy prison sentence, the source of the stolen silencer and the full extent of Mink’s network remain unclear, leaving open the possibility that other individuals involved may still be operating in the shadows. The forfeited firearms will be processed and destroyed according to federal protocol.

Related Federal Cases