Deerfield Beach, FL – On June 5, 2006, Judge Daniel T.K. Hurley of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida issued a consent order against Steve Knowles and four others, imposing over $10 million in sanctions for commodity fraud. The case, initially filed in June 2004, centers around deceptive practices employed by First American Investment Services, Inc., a Florida corporation, and its sales staff.
According to court documents, from December 2002 through August 2003, First American fraudulently solicited public investors with high-pressure sales tactics to open accounts with Universal Financial Holding Corporation for commodity futures options trading. Prospective customers were falsely promised substantial and rapid returns with minimal risk, a claim the CFTC deemed misleading.
Sales representatives, including Michael Savitsky III, Greg Allotta, James Eulo, and Adam Mills, routinely misrepresented potential profits by linking them to predictable world events, such as Middle Eastern crises, falsely suggesting guaranteed gains. The CFTC argued that such claims ignored the realities of efficient markets, which quickly incorporate public information into contract prices, and the inherent risks associated with options trading.
The result was devastating for investors. Over 97% of First American’s 700 customers lost money, totaling over $11 million in losses, with First American retaining over half of that amount in commissions. Steve Knowles, as president of First American, was found liable for knowingly controlling the operations that led to the violations or failing to address them.
The consent order permanently enjoins Knowles, First American, Savitsky, Allotta, Mills, and Eulo from future violations of the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA). The defendants are jointly and severally liable for repaying nearly $8 million to customers, with First American owing $7,983,388, Knowles $1,600,000, Allotta $1,137,000, Savitsky $660,000, Mills $250,000 and Eulo $200,000. Additionally, civil monetary penalties totaling over $2 million were levied: First American $1,000,000, Knowles $400,000, Allotta $373,000, Savitsky $140,000, Mills $75,000 and Eulo $75,000.
The CFTC’s case was led by Mark Bretscher, Susan Padove, William Heitner, Robert Greenwald, Rosemary Hollinger, and Joan Manley of the Division of Enforcement.
Source: CFTC.gov
Related Federal Cases
- Orlando Pascual Jr., HIV Treatment Medicare Fraud, Miami FL, 2023 · Mississippi
- Juan A. Tony Marrero, Medicare Fraud Scheme, Miami FL, 2023 · Texas
- Juan A. Tony Marrero, Medicare Fraud Scheme, Miami FL, 2024 · Florida
- Alton Plunkett, Tax Fraud, New York NY, 2023 · New York
- Letitia James, Tax Fraud and Bribery, New York 2023 · New York

