Eugene Smith, Counterfeit Ticket Trafficking, Georgia 2023

Eugene Smith, 45, of Lithonia, GA, is going to prison for 51 months after being convicted of running a nationwide counterfeit ticket operation that ripped off sports fans at the Super Bowl, NCAA Championships, and NBA All-Star games. Smith was found guilty of conspiracy to commit wire fraud, wire fraud, conspiracy to traffic in counterfeit goods, and trafficking in counterfeit goods, all tied to his central role in manufacturing and moving fake tickets worth hundreds of thousands of dollars.

The scam was built on greed and deception. Smith targeted marquee events—Super Bowl LI in Houston, Super Bowl LII in Minneapolis, major college football and basketball title games, and high-profile concerts—because they promised the biggest payouts. He supplied authentic tickets to a co-conspirator printer, who replicated them with near-perfect precision, including official holograms and trademarks registered with the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office. These weren’t backyard photocopies—they were sophisticated fakes designed to fool even seasoned ticket-takers.

Smith didn’t just sell the tickets himself. He distributed them to a network of street vendors and resellers across the country, flooding venues with counterfeit access. Fans who paid top dollar for what they thought were once-in-a-lifetime experiences were left stranded at gates, holding worthless paper. The face value of the forged tickets totaled at least $170,000, but investigators say the actual resale value—especially for Super Bowl seats—was many times higher.

At sentencing, the mask came off. Eric Ferguson, the man who printed the tickets, testified that Smith recruited him and directed the entire operation. Ferguson’s cooperation laid bare the mechanics of the scheme: real tickets used as templates, bulk printing runs, and last-minute drops at stadiums where desperate fans would bite. The FBI’s investigation peeled back layers of coordination, showing Smith wasn’t a lone hustler—he was the ring leader of a calculated fraud enterprise.

“This case isn’t just about taking advantage of sports fans’ willingness to spend their hard-earned dollars to enjoy a game; this is about ensuring that consumers of all types can trust that when they spend their money, they are getting the authentic product for which they paid,” said U.S. Attorney William M. McSwain. “Smith is nothing more than a con-artist and thief, and I’m grateful that the judge saw it that way and gave him a sentence that ensures justice for his victims.”

The case was investigated by the Federal Bureau of Investigation and prosecuted by Assistant United States Attorneys Joan E. Burnes and Anita Eve. Smith’s 51-month sentence sends a message: selling illusion comes at a real price.

Related Federal Cases