NEW ORLEANS, LOUISIANA – A jury in the Middle District of Alabama delivered a damning verdict Friday, convicting a New Orleans legal duo and their firms in a brazen scheme to defraud insurance companies through staged car accidents. VANESSA MOTTA, 44, and JASON F. GILES, 47, were found guilty on all counts following a grueling three-week trial overseen by Chief U.S. District Judge Wendy B. Vitter. The feds say the pair weren’t working alone.
The indictment detailed a calculated operation where accidents were deliberately manufactured to generate bogus injury claims. The jury didn’t just point the finger at MOTTA and GILES; they also convicted their law firms, MOTTA LAW LLC and THE KING FIRM LLC, as active participants in the conspiracy. The firms allegedly served as the central hub for processing fraudulent claims, raking in cash from payouts secured through deceit.
Adding another layer to the criminal enterprise, DIAMANIKE F. STALBERT, 35, was also found guilty. STALBERT’s role, according to federal prosecutors, was to recruit individuals to participate in the staged collisions, essentially providing the bodies needed to fuel the fraudulent claims machine. Details of the exact charges against each defendant haven’t been released, but sources close to the investigation suggest they include conspiracy to commit fraud and multiple counts of mail fraud.
This isn’t just a case of a few bad apples. The scope of the scheme suggests a systematic effort to exploit the insurance system, potentially costing companies millions. The feds have been building this case for months, meticulously gathering evidence of orchestrated accidents, falsified medical records, and illicit financial transactions. This conviction sends a clear message: manipulating the legal system for personal gain will not be tolerated.
The trial showcased a network of deception, with witnesses detailing how MOTTA and GILES allegedly pressured participants to stick to scripted narratives and conceal the true nature of the accidents. The defense attempted to portray the claims as legitimate, but the jury clearly saw through the smokescreen. The verdicts against the law firms themselves are particularly significant, signaling a willingness by the courts to hold corporations accountable for enabling criminal activity.
Sentencing dates have not yet been set for VANESSA MOTTA, JASON F. GILES, or DIAMANIKE F. STALBERT. However, given the severity of the charges and the scope of the fraud, lengthy prison sentences are widely expected. This case underscores the ongoing battle against insurance fraud and the lengths to which some will go to enrich themselves at the expense of others. The Grimy Times will continue to follow this case as it moves toward sentencing and potential asset forfeiture.
Related Federal Cases
Key Facts
- State: Alabama
- District: Middle District District of Alabama
- Category: White Collar Crime|Organized Crime|Fraud & Financial Crimes
- Source: DOJ Press Release
🔒 Get the grimiest stories delivered weekly. Subscribe free →
Browse More
