Nicholas Munson Troemner, Possession of a Firearm and Ammunition as a Convicted Felon, Florida 2023

NORTH FORT MYERS, FL – Nicholas Munson Troemner, 41, of Marco Island, is looking at a potential 15-year stretch in federal prison after pleading guilty to possession of a firearm and ammunition as a convicted felon. The bust, a result of an investigation by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF), highlights the ongoing struggle to keep guns out of the hands of those legally barred from owning them.

The incident unfolded February 16, 2023, in North Fort Myers. Troemner was found to be packing a loaded Taurus pistol. But this wasn’t a simple weapons violation. Court documents reveal a pattern of prior convictions – multiple felony counts related to both firearms and narcotics. That history automatically disqualifies him from legally possessing any firearms or ammunition under federal law, a fact Troemner apparently ignored.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Mark Morgan is prosecuting the case, and as part of a plea agreement, Troemner has agreed to forfeit the pistol and ammunition seized during his arrest. While the exact sentencing date remains unconfirmed, the maximum penalty of 15 years sends a clear message about the federal government’s stance on repeat offenders and illegal gun possession.

U.S. Attorney Roger B. Handberg, speaking for the Middle District of Florida, framed the case as part of the broader “Project Safe Neighborhoods” (PSN) initiative. This is the standard boilerplate – a program touted by the Department of Justice that aims to unite law enforcement at all levels with local communities to curb violent crime and gun violence. It’s a lot of talk, but the reality is this case landed in federal court because Troemner allegedly broke the law, plain and simple.

The PSN strategy, resurrected and reinforced in 2021, focuses on building trust with communities, supporting local anti-violence groups, and concentrating enforcement efforts on the most pressing threats. But for Troemner, it’s too late for prevention. He’s already a convicted felon, and now faces the consequences of again violating federal firearms laws.

The ATF’s Tampa Field Division spearheaded the investigation, demonstrating a continued commitment to tackling gun-related crime in Florida. While authorities celebrate this conviction as a win for public safety, the question remains: how many more repeat offenders are still out there, illegally armed and posing a threat to communities across the state?

MORE FEDERAL CRIME NEWS

Weapons

Matthew Shannon Hartley, Ammunition Possession, Alabama 2023

Dec 1, 2021

Weapons

Jose Alcaraz Guerrero, Loaded Firearm Possession, California 2020

Aug 21, 2023

Weapons

Ramon Oscar Morales-Valencia, Alien in Possession of a Firearm, Oregon 2025

Jul 16, 2026

Weapons

Isaac Hernandez, Handgun Trafficking, California 2022

Feb 10, 2023