James Defends NYC Sanctuary Policies in DOJ Fight

NEW YORK – New York Attorney General Letitia James is throwing down in a legal battle with the Department of Justice (DOJ) over New York City’s sanctuary laws. James filed an amicus curiae brief today, defending the city’s policies that limit local law enforcement’s involvement in federal immigration enforcement. The DOJ, under the current administration, is attempting to dismantle these laws, arguing they hinder federal efforts. James isn’t backing down, framing the fight as a defense of public safety and the rights of immigrant communities.

The core of the dispute centers around laws enacted in NYC dating back to the 1980s, supported by both Republican and Democratic administrations. These laws restrict city officials from cooperating with federal immigration authorities on civil detentions and inquiries. The Attorney General’s filing argues these policies are essential for maintaining trust between immigrant communities and law enforcement. Without that trust, witnesses are less likely to come forward, and crimes go unreported, leaving all New Yorkers vulnerable. “Our city was built by immigrants, and the attempts of this administration to revoke the laws that protect them are unjust and unconstitutional,” James stated bluntly.

The DOJ initiated legal action in July 2025, challenging the legality of NYC’s sanctuary policies. The federal government alleges the city is obstructing federal law. James’ brief counters that the city’s laws are entirely consistent with both state and federal statutes. Crucially, the laws do not prevent cooperation on criminal matters; they simply limit involvement in civil immigration enforcement. New York State law doesn’t grant local police the authority to arrest individuals based solely on civil immigration violations, even at the request of federal Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE).

The Attorney General’s office points to research demonstrating the positive impact of sanctuary policies on public safety. Studies show that a significant percentage of immigrants – over half, including more than two-thirds of undocumented individuals – are hesitant to report crimes or provide information to police for fear of immigration inquiries. By creating a safe environment for reporting, the city encourages cooperation and helps solve crimes that might otherwise go unsolved. This isn’t about ignoring the law, it’s about effective policing.

James’ filing urges the United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York to dismiss the DOJ’s lawsuit. She argues the federal government’s attempt to overturn local laws is not only legally flawed but also detrimental to the safety and well-being of New York City residents. This case sets a dangerous precedent, she warns, potentially opening the door for federal overreach into local law enforcement matters across the country.

The fight is far from over, and legal experts predict a protracted battle. But Letitia James is making it clear: she’s prepared to defend New York City’s sanctuary policies, and the communities they protect, with everything she’s got. This isn’t just a legal argument; it’s a statement about the values of New York City – a city that, for generations, has welcomed immigrants and relied on their contributions to build a vibrant, diverse, and safe community. The court will decide if that tradition will continue.

RELATED: James Takes Stand to Protect Immigrant Communities in NYC